Kitchens Sync

Clone and Boot: Another Advantage of the Mac OS

- 2008.08.28 - Tip Jar

Popularity: Bookmark in

One of the most useful - and I believe coolest - features of the Mac OS is the amazing flexibility of the operating system. Specifically, I am referring to the ability of the OS to be copied from one computer to another without a need for reinstall.

Compared to Windows, the Mac OS is like a double jointed gymnast.

One Installation, Many Macs

Something that most people may not realize is that an installed copy of the Mac OS can be almost endlessly copied and instantly run on any Mac for which there is basic hardware support (e.g. you can't clone Panther to an Intel or a newer PowerPC Mac, because you would get a kernel panic on boot due to a lack of support for the newer hardware).

This principle forms the basis of Low End Mac's Unsupported Leopard page. If I so desired, I could buy a copy of Leopard and install it on an external drive using my fairly new Intel-based iMac. I could then attach my eMac in Target Disk Mode and clone the Leopard installation to it using Carbon Copy Cloner or SuperDuper.

The only reason I would even have to use the external drive would be to get around the GPT (GUID Partition Table)/APM (Apple Partition Map) formatting problem. Intel Macs can only install the Mac OS to GPT drives, although they can boot from either GPT or APM drives. PowerPC Macs can only boot from APM drives. Thus the clone is necessary to move the copy of Leopard onto an APM drive.

My 700 MHz eMac doesn't even meet the minimum requirements for Leopard; it lacks 167 MHz of processor speed and 192 MB of RAM. The only thing that matters in this scenario is the G4 compatibility compiled into Leopard.

This procedure also works with the Classic Mac OS, though I find one must be more careful with version numbers than in OS X. Through time I ended up with a clamshell iBook and CRT iMac and only one set of OS 9 discs for an even older clamshell iBook that no longer functioned. I could install the system on the iMac, as it was the only one that could boot from the discs. Then, after updating the system to 9.2.2, I would copy the contents to the iBook, which would work flawlessly.

Unfortunately, when I tried to clone the system to my eMac, I ended up with no sound or 3D graphics. I suspect that the problem lies in an old ROM file in the System Folder that predates the eMac.

Well That Didn't Work

From experiments and experience, I have learned that this feat is impossible to do on Windows. Believe me, I have wasted many hours trying to get it to work. My attempt was simple: I was moving a Parallels system to the recently released VMware Fusion for my math teacher. I followed VMware's instructions to the letter. My new image booted fine, though it complained of needing reactivation. However, I had to do a repair install of Windows to change to an ACPI Multiprocessor HAL.

This was necessary for two reasons. First, one of the reasons my teacher moved to VMware was its support for two virtual processors. Second, the virtual machine couldn't automatically shut down because Parallels virtual machines used the older APM HAL.

After I performed the process, the system developed several massive bugs. For example, Windows Update simply ceased to function, leaving security vulnerabilities. After spending hours trying to fix this, I eventually ended up with a non-system disk, which for those unfamiliar with Windows means that the system will not boot. At that point I turned to my teacher and exclaimed, "Well that didn't work!"

In the end, I ended up reinstalling Windows.

Come on, Microsoft. You can move an installed copy of Mac OS X between two different processor architectures and it won't bat an eye. Your OS is far too rigid and brittle.

Apple Bailed Me Out

If it wasn't for this feature, I would have been in deep trouble many times.

When I once managed to install the core system for an Intel Mac onto my eMac, generating an unbootable system, my Panther iBook saved me. I was able to boot my iBook in Target Disk mode and boot my eMac from the iBook's hard drive until I could get it fixed. Thankfully, the fantastic support people of the Apple Store's Genius Bar were kind enough to reinstall Tiger for free. As an aside, make sure and generously thank the Genius Bar staff when they fix your problems. Trust me, they deserve it.

If Apple were to integrate some kind of copy protection, such as what has been rumored, scads of people wouldn't be able to use yet another feature that makes the Mac superior. LEM

Join us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Google+, or subscribe to our RSS news feed

If you find Kevin's articles helpful, please consider making a donation to his tip jar.

Today's Links

Recent Content

About LEM Support Usage Privacy Contact

Follow Low End Mac on Twitter
Join Low End Mac on Facebook

Favorite Sites

Cult of Mac
Shrine of Apple
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
The Vintage Mac Museum
Deal Brothers
Mac Driver Museum
JAG's House
System 6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End Mac FAQ

The iTunes Store
PC Connection Express
Macgo Blu-ray Player
Parallels Desktop for Mac

Low End Mac's store


Open Link

Low End Mac's store


Open Link