Quandary: OS 9, OS X, or Linux?

My Turn is Low End Mac's column for reader-submitted articles. It's your turn to share your thoughts on all things Mac (or iPhone, iPod, etc.) and write for the Mac web. Email your submission to Dan Knight .

Nancy Butts - reply by Dan Knight - 2001.11.07

What an interesting juxtaposition of articles you posted today (11/1): Kevin Webb's piece on being stuck between OS 9 and OS X; Jim Champlin's helpful overview of a "normal" user's experience with 10.1; and poor Walter's lament about the high cost of Apple repair.

It spoke to the quandary I find myself in since the introduction of OS X - not just when should I upgrade, but if I should upgrade. I am a "normal" user, by which I mean I use my Macs to get work done. I have weekly deadlines which require that I be able to print, sync with my Palm IIIxe, scan and fax documents, backup to an external hard drive, use an external floppy, and link to my trusty old PowerBook 170 via an AppleTalk network. There are all things I need to do-they aren't optional. But as I understand it, they are all things I either cannot do at all right now via OS X or cannot do without spending money to upgrade all my peripherals and most of my software.

So upgrading to OS X is going to cost me cash, and a lot of it. But it's also going to cost me something even more precious: time. I'm going to need time to install and learn a brand new operating system. And as thin as my wallet is these days, my store of spare time is even more meager.

Meanwhile, I have set up a nice little system on my Rev. B iMac using OS 8.6 that does everything I need to do and does it well. Analyzing my particular situation this way, I've concluded that OS X offers me no short-term benefits. I don't even see any reason to upgrade to OS 9.

However, I realize that as attached as I am to my low-end Mac home office network, the day will come when there is a piece of software I want or need that is only going to run on OS X. And as I understand it, in order to maintain and troubleshoot OS X, it's necessary to learn at least a little Unix. Thinking ahead to that day when I have to abandon my beloved old Mac OS, I am beginning to wonder - do I upgrade to OS X at all? Or should I think outside the Apple box and migrate to Linux? There are familiar GUIs that one can run on top of Linux, and much of the software is free. Either way I'm going to have to bite the bullet and learn the arcana of a mysterious command line interface again (as I did long ago with DOS).

I'm not a techie. I admit that there's a lot I don't know about OS X and its underpinnings, much less about Linux and how it works. And the idea of jumping the Apple ship and adopting Linux is scary. So I'm asking - what are the advantages and disadvantages, for a "normal" user, of OS X v. Linux? This is an article I'd love to see on Low End Mac.

I'm in a similar situation. I'd like to learn Mac OS X and get comfortable with the next great OS, especially now that 10.1 seems to have solved a lot of the speed issues and other shortcomings of the 10.0.x releases. Like you, I have no compelling reason to do so.

First, all of my software runs under the classic Mac OS. Sure, I could run it in classic mode under OS X, but why add the extra overhead. Second, there is no piece of software yet available that I need. Third, I am a creature of habit.

I've been using pretty much the same programs since the System 7.5.x era: Claris Emailer 2, Claris Home Page 3, ClarisWorks (now AppleWorks), BBEdit Lite, Mizer (an old and discontinued HTML compression program), TextSoap, ramBunctious, FileMaker Pro, Photoshop 4, GraphicConverter, MenuChoice, Default Menu, Copy Agent (formerly Speed Doubler), QuicKeys, and who knows how many other little programs and utilities. Some of these are available as X applications, but most are not. That means I would have to switch between OS X and classic applications constantly - it's so much easier to only deal with one OS.

As for Linux vs. Mac OS X, things are not a pretty on the Linux side of the street as Linux users might lead you to believe. For the most part, Linux applications are home-brew copies of Windows classics such as Word, Excel, Photoshop, Illustrator, etc. Quality varies, and from my reading it seems that few, if any, of these cloneware titles have the polish, feature set, and support we're used to with commercial software.

Linux, which is itself not Unix but a clone of Unix, fills a niche for geeks and those who need rock solid servers. Mac OS X, on the other hand, is Unix, and the applications designed for Mac OS X offer the same kind of polish, features, and support Mac users expect.

Another point to consider is that Mac OS X is specifically designed for Mac hardware by Apple and may already be the top *nix implementation on desktop computers.

If you want to dabble, Linux and a spare Mac may be a great inexpensive way to do so, but for those with modern (G3 or later) Apple hardware, Mac OS X is definitely the future. For most of us, it's just a question of when the right piece of software will come along that forces our hand and gets us to adopt it.

Share your perspective on the Mac by emailing with "My Turn" as your subject.

Recent My Turn articles

• Using Low End Macs for Internet Radio, 08.18. When the local public radio station moved classical music to HD radio, it was time to find another way to listen. An old iMac with iTunes solved the problem.
• 'That's Not a Computer', 07.30. Salvaging a broken PowerBook by turning it into a desktop computer.
• Upgrading a Digital Audio G4 to work better in Leopard, 06.02. In its original configuration, the dual 533 MHz Power Mac G4 was slow with Mac OS X 10.5, but add the right upgrades, and it runs Leopard quite nicely.
• My 4 favorite PowerBooks, 05.28. The PowerBook 150 has a big screen for a vintage PowerBook, the 165c has color, the 100 is diminutive, and Lombard has USB and a great keyboard.
• More in the My Turn index.

Links for the Day

• Mac of the Day: PowerBook 170, Oct. 1991 - At 25 MHz, the PB 170 was at the top of the original PowerBook line.
• List of the Day: The iPhone List Low End Mac's forum for discussing and supporting Apple's iPhone.
  
• August 30 in LEM history: 99: The truth about USB speed - 00: Could Eazel kill the Mac? - Mac OS 8.1 on a IIci and LC III - 01: Beyond MHz and GHz - Getting a handle on email - Thanks for the IBM PC, Dad - Apple's anniversaries - 02: Mac OS X v10.2 - iBook video out - 04: Things that freak out my students - 06: Nvu and SeaMonkey can't replace Home Page - 07: DVD-RAM support

Recent Content on Low End Mac

• Looking for a Content Management System That's as Easy as Mac, Dan Knight, Mac Musings, 08.29. Low End Mac needs to move to a content management system, but the few we've tried just don't cut it for people used to the simple elegance of the Mac.
• First 3 Million Mac Quarter, Skinny on Mac mini Pricing, Mac-like gOS, and More, Mac News Review, 08.29. More plan to buy Apple products than ever before, complete reset can fix MobileMac synch problems, Apple boosting computer and smartphone share, and more.
• New 'Books Likely in September, 17" PowerBook Display Fault Site, SSD Security, and More, The 'Book Review, 08.29. Also 6 ways to speed up your MacBook, next generation MacBook Air CPU, MacBook Air Update, LapStrap carrying solution, rise and fall of ultraportables, bargains from $220 to $2,699, and more.
• iPhone 3G Reception 'Completely Normal', AT&T International Data Plans for iPhone, and More, iNews Review, 08.29. Also longer life for iPod earbuds, an alternative to MobileMe, new cases and apps for iPhone, AppStoreGems website launched, and more.
• Best Power Mac G4 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.29. Used 450 MHz AGP, $75; 500, $99; 800 QS, $199; 1.25 GHz MDD, $375; 450 MHz dual, $179; 867 dual, $300; 1 GHz dual, $395; 1.42 dual, $575.
• Best iBook G3 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.29. Used 300 MHz clamshell, $150; 500 CD, $150; 800, $200; 600 CD-RW, $240; 900 Combo, $300; 14" 600, $360; 900, $400.
• Best iPod nano Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.29. Used 2 GB iPod nano, $89; refurb 3G 4 GB, $99; new, $140; refurb 8 GB, $149; new, $179.
• 10 Mac Browsers Compared, Simon Royal, Mac Spectrum, 08.28. A look at Internet Explorer, Radon, Opera, Safari, Shiira, iCab, Firefox, Netscape Navigator, Flock, and Camino running in Leopard.
• Clone and Boot: Another Advantage of the Mac OS, Kev Kitchens, Kitchens Sync, 08.28. Unlike Windows, Apple makes it possible to clone a bootable drive (Classic Mac OS or OS X) and use it with another supported Mac.
• Best MacBook Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.28. Used 1.83 GHz, $799; 2.0 black, $875; refurb 2.1 GHz, $899; 2.4, $1,099; black, $1,299; new 2.1, $1,019 after rebate; 22, $1,094; 2.4, $1,219 a/r; black, $1,394 a/r.
• Best iMac G5 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.28. Used 17" 1.6 GHz Combo, $499; 1.8 SuperDrive, $530; 2.0, $600; 1.9 iSight, $625; 20" 1.8 GHz, $580; 2.0, $650; 2.1 iSight, $700.
• Best classic Mac OS Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.28. System 6, $10; 7.1, $12; 7.5.1, $4; Mac OS 7.6, $13; 8.0, $13; 8.1, $48; 8.5, $25; 8.6, $20; 9.0, $20; 9.2.2, $20; more.
• CrossOver Strikes Out, Frank Fox, Stop the Noiz, 08.27. Running Windows apps on a Mac without paying for Windows is great in theory, but actually getting Windows software working is another story.
• MacDrought: 4 Months with No New Macs, Dan Knight, Mac Musings, 08.27. The most recent Mac update was over four months ago, and the Mac mini has been unchanged for over a year.
• Resurrecting a Dead Pismo, Spotlight Search Tip, and EasyFind a Good File Finder, Charles W. Moore, Miscellaneous Ramblings, 08.27. Lots of tips on bringing a comatose Pismo back to life, a Spotlight file name search tip, and EasyFind as an alternative to Spotlight.
• Best Intel iMac Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.27. Used 17" 1.83 GHz, $625; 20", $599; 2.16, $749; 24", $950; refurb 20" 2.4, $999; 2.66, $1,299; 24" 2.4, $1,299; 2.8, $1,549; new 3.06, $2,094 after rebate; more.
• Best 15" PowerBook G4 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.27. Used 1.25 GHz Combo, $600; SuperDrive, $650; 1.33 Combo, $640; 1.5, $680; SD, $725; 1.67, $730; hi-res, $800.
• Best Time Capsule and AirPort Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.27. 500 GB Time Capsule, $294; 1 TB, $468; AirPort Extreme Card, $39; 802.11n Base Station, $166; 802.11g AirPort Express, $60; 802.11n, $98.
• More links in our archive.