Low End Mac Reader Specials

TypeStyler For Mac OS X is Now Shipping! Download The Free Fully Functional 60 Day Tryout at www.typestyler.com

Poker Mac Don't install Parallels to play poker online! Poker Mac will show you how to download and install a native Mac poker application such as Full Tilt Poker Mac.

Laptop Hardware Provided by TechRestore - Overnight Mac & iPod Repairs.

Compare products like desktop computers, apple laptops, apple macs, and LCD Monitors side by side! All the information and reviews to make the best purchasing decision for new mobile phones, sat nav systems, or MP3 players. The Ciao online shopping community makes searching products easy for you.

Mac USB & FireWire

The Ethernet Alternative to USB Drives

Dan Knight - 1999.09.08

USB is slower than promised, providing at most half the expected bandwidth (see The Truth About USB Speed). But the iMac, iBook, and Lombard PowerBook don't have any other option, do they?

Maybe.

Running daily backup on a network of 70-some Macs, I know backup over 10Base-T ethernet can hit 62 MB/min. - twice the best backup speed I've seen reported for a USB tape drive. (FYI, backing up over Ultra SCSI on a Blue G3/300 can break 1709 MB/min.)

Of course, performance varies by computer. The fastest backup is on G3 machines; the slowest on 68030-based Macs.

It got me thinking: is a Mac on ethernet a viable alternative to USB hard drives?

I did some testing over 10Base-T ethernet to see what kind of throughput you can expect over a network. I copied 79 files (total of 5.2 MB) to three different Macs to see if network performance was in the USB ballpark. Here are the results. (Note that results might be faster with 100Base-T, which I don't have access to.)

Quadra 800, Mac OS 8.1, file sharing

125.8 MBps

1.0 Mbps

iMac Rev. B, Mac OS 8.6, file sharing

234.9 MBps

1.9 Mbps

Power Mac 7600/200, Mac OS 8.6, AppleShare IP

435.9 MBps

3.5 Mbps

Not quite as fast as USB - and far more expensive once we move to Power Macs with AppleShare IP. The least expensive alternative, a Quadra with an ethernet card, will probably set you back $100 to $200. You can drop a huge SCSI or IDE drive into it fairly cheaply, but it also requires a keyboard, mouse, and monitor. The whole setup can easily set you back $300-400.

On the other hand, it gives you a second Macintosh and a drive that can be shared on a network with as many Macs as you can put on the network. And you can set it up for Remote Access or as a shared internet connection for multiple computers. Network performance is about one-quarter that of a USB hard drive.

Switching to an iMac, we double throughput, but with a much higher price tag. You'll probably spend $800 for an iMac/233, then another $100-200 for a huge hard drive to replace what's inside. If you already have an iMac, you're probably better off putting that huge hard drive in the iMac you're already using.

The third choice is to run AppleShare IP, which offers nearly twice the performance of personal file sharing on the iMac. You'll want a 604-based Power Mac or clone (or better), which will cost $600 and up on the used market. Then spend $450 for a ten-user copy of AppleShare IP and add a huge ($200 or so) hard drive.

None of these are inexpensive solutions. Of those tested, only the AppleShare IP server offered the same performance as a USB hard drive.

On the other hard, all of these solutions provide a second computer and can be shared with an entire network. USB drives are attached to only one computer at a time, although it should be possible to share them over a network with File Sharing.

Conclusion

Is ethernet a viable alternative to a USB hard drive?

I can't speak conclusively, since I don't yet have a 100Base-T network to test, but it looks like it's not a cost effective alternative to a USB hard drive.

That said, the best way to find out for certain would be to connect USB drive to a Mac on a 100Base-T network and do further testing.

However, there are some benefits to networking even a slower, older Mac to an iMac, Blue G3, iBook, or Lombard PowerBook. The first is that you'd have a floppy drive, which you can use for making disk images to use on your newer Mac. With few exceptions, almost all installers work equally well from a disk image as from the original floppy. That could save you $100-180.

Another advantage of a second Mac is that it provides a second work station, letting others use a Mac while you're using the newer one.

But the biggest advantage is that as you add Macs, you already have a central place to store files for all your computers.

The biggest advantages of a USB hard drive are storage cost (IDE drives are far less costly per MB than SCSI drives) and plug-and-play portability.

Look for a follow-up in October, when I'll have access to a 100Base-T network. LEM

Further Reading

Links for the Day

Recent Content

Recent Deals

About LEM | Support | Usage | Privacy | Contacts

Entire Low End Mac website copyright ©1997-2009 by Cobweb Publishing, Inc., unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved. Advice presented in good faith, but what works for one may not work for all. Please report errors to .
  LINKS: We allow and encourage links to any public page as long as the linked page does not appear within a frame that prevents bookmarking it.
  Access our RSS news feed at http://lowendmac.com/feed.xml.
  Email may be published at our discretion; email addresses will not be published without permission, and we will encrypt them in hopes of avoiding spammers. If you prefer your message not be published, mark it "not for publication." Letters may be edited for length, context, and to match house style.
  PRIVACY: We don't collect personal information unless you explicitly provide it. For more details, see our Terms of Use.
  Low End Mac is an independent publication and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Apple Inc. Apple, the Apple logo, Macintosh, iBook, iMac, eMac, iPod, iPhone, PowerBook, MacBook, MagSafe, Mac Pro, Apple TV, and AirPort are registered trademarks of Apple Inc. Additional company and product names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are hereby acknowledged.

Custom Search

Amazon.com

Navigation

Used Mac Dealers
Apple History
Video Cards
Email Lists

Favorite Sites

MacSurfer
MacMinute
MacInTouch
MyAppleMenu
InfoMac
Macs Only!
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
RetroMacCast
PB Central
MacWindows
The Vintage Mac
   Museum
DealMac
DealsOnTheWeb
Mac2Sell
ramseeker
Mac Driver Museum
JAG's House
System 6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End
   Mac FAQ
Abandonware
   Petition
Mac vs. PC Info

Affiliates

The Apple Store
Mac Connection
B&H
MacMall
TechRestore
ExperCom
Crucial Memory
batteries.com

Advertise

All of our advertising is handled by BackBeat Media. For price quotes and advertising information, please contact at BackBeat Media (646-546-5194). This number is for advertising only.

Open Link

Problems viewing this page with Internet Explorer 5.5 or 6? It works fine in other browsers, including IE 7. We recommend Firefox for those using Windows, as it is standards based and more secure than IE 6 (and earlier). More LEM visitors use Firefox than any other browser.