BIAX vs. Apple, Part 2
- 2001.10.09
Low End Mac Reader Specials
Memory To Go Special: MacPro 8 Core Memory 4GB kit $154 / 2GB kit $94, New 2008 iMac 2GB $46. MacBook Pro / MacMini / iMac Intel Core2 DUO 2GB $44 / 1GB $23--Free shipping available.
Download Typestyler, still the Ultimate Styling Tool for Internet, Print and Video Graphics. Works great in Classic with a Native OS X Version on the way. Free Tryout: www.typestyler.com
LA Computer Company: Specials on AppleCare, iMac's, Apple Batteries and Apple A/C Adapters. Also Great prices on Used Apple Computers. Call 1-800-941-7654 Click Here.
OWC: Top Quality Memory for Faster Mac Performance 1GB/2GB/4GB Kits from $23.99/$47.99/$94.99 Expert Support, Free Installation Videos & Guides, Lifetime Advance Replacement Warranty - www.MacSales.com
Mac users can finally play Party Poker for Mac. Not only that, they can also learn how to play PokerStars for Mac.
Laptop Hardware Provided by TechRestore - Overnight Mac & iPod Repairs.
Compare products like desktop computers, laptops, and LCD TVs side by side! All the information and reviews to make the best purchasing decision for a new cell phone GPS products or MP3 players. The Ciao network makes searching products easy for you.
New iMac 800Mhz Memory 4GB $98, 2GB $50. Click to Maximize your Macs...
Apple was recently sued by a previously unknown company named BIAX, alleging patent infringement. In last week's article, we took a look at the legal framework of the case. This week, we conclude our two-part series by looking at how, or if, any Apple products might infringe on these patents.
At issue are two patents filed by the Plaintiff (BIAX): June 6, 1994: "Computer with instructions that use an address field to select among multiple condition code registers," and June 7, 1995: "Parallel processor system for processing natural concurrencies and method therefor." As an opening observation, let me say that as best I can ascertain from reading these two patents, their primary focus is on the processor. To date, the only named Defendant in this lawsuit is Apple Computer, Inc. As many times as I have been to Cupertino, I have never seen the Apple chip fabrication facility. Where is Steve Jobs cranking out all those PowerPC G3 and G4 processors? In the basement somewhere? Initially, at least, it seems this Plaintiff has the wrong Defendant.
Here is a quote from the original Reuters article reporting the filing of the lawsuit: "According to Slobodin [the Plaintiff's attorney], the patents in question improve the efficiency and speed of parallel processing of a computer's central processing unit (CPU)." "Parallel processing allows the CPU to perform many simultaneous tasks," Slobodin said.
This lawsuit alleges that Apple "makes and sells computers that are covered by the patents." Let's examine the logic of this allegation. If these patents apply to the PowerPC processors at all, they probably apply to most RISC-based processors. That being the case, doesn't Sun also "make and sell computers that are covered by the patents?" What about IBM and their higher-end servers? Most Hewlett-Packard laser printers use a RISC processor.
The second patent may apply to most, if not all, multiprocessor systems. If I go down to the local computer store and buy the right parts, I can also "make and sell computers that are covered by the patents." Where does it end?
It is generally the company which manufactures the allegedly infringing part that must be sued. If it is the CPU which violates the patent(s), that company is not Apple; it is IBM and Motorola that make the processors.
Why has Apple been singled out? I can't begin to speculate what may be going through the minds of those in power at this company (BIAX), but it certainly looks like some coincidence that this lawsuit was filed at a time when Apple is perhaps more flush with cash than they have ever been in their history.
The BIAX attorney has said that they are considering filing similar lawsuits against "other unnamed computer manufacturers." It will be very interesting to follow this case and see if any other manufacturers are named. This may give us insight as to exactly what the alleged infringements are.
Technical considerations aside, it is entirely possible - even likely - that there may be no legal infringement upon the patents in question at all. As I noted last week, one cannot go out and patent an invention which has already been brought to market if the individual seeking the patent did not in fact invent the product. The PowerPC processor predates even the earliest of these patents by over two years. In fact, Apple's release of its first computer featuring the PowerPC chip also predates the earliest patent by three months. Certainly multiprocessor RISC systems from other manufacturers predate both patents as well. It is important here to clarify that the G3 and G4 are merely different models of the PowerPC processor, just as the 601, 603ev, 604(e), etc.
It is the existence of this "prior art" which may hold the key to this lawsuit. Apple, as well as any other companies which may be subsequently sued, must prove that the "inventions" described in these patents already existed at the time the patent applications were filed, and that the party who filed the applications had nothing to do with their invention. If that can be proved, the USPTO will invalidate the patents.
Will this happen? This case is in much too early a stage to venture a prediction with any certainty. It will be analyzed by electrical engineers who are so intimately familiar with CPUs that they could build one in their sleep. After a cursory analysis by a layperson, I would have to say the call is, "Advantage Apple." However, only after an in-depth analysis by these engineers will we be able to make a real judgment as to the likely outcome.
We will continue to follow this case and keep our readers informed
as the events unfold. 
Further Reading
- Computer with instructions that use an address field to select among multiple condition code registers, US Patent Office
- Parallel processor system for processing natural concurrencies and method therefor, US Patent Office
- Apple Computer sued for alleged patent infringement, Yahoo/Reuters, 2001:09:06
- Apple sued for patent infringement, Slashdot, 2001:09:07
- Tech Week in Review, 2001:09:07
- Apple sued for parallel processing, MacSlash, 2001:09:07
Steve Watkins is the Vice President for Information Technology for a mid-sized bank and also an attorney. He has been a Mac user for about ten years. He has owned some PCs along the way - but always came back to the Mac. If you find Steve's's articles helpful, please consider making a donation to his tip jar.
Recent Practical Mac Articles
- 5 things Apple is doing right in 2008 - and 5 it could do better, 03.24. Apple has made great strides in the past five years, but there are still a few areas that need to be addressed.
- MacBook Air a compelling option for the true road warrior, 02.22. Although it's not intended as a desktop replacement and has a few shortcomings, the lightweight MacBook Air with its 13" display could be the perfect field computer.
- Mailsmith a simple, powerful, spam fighting alternative to Apple Mail, 04.23. Mailsmith is bundled with SpamSieve, integrates with Address Book, and has very flexible scripting tools combined with elegant simplicity.
- More in the Practical Mac index.
Recent Content on Low End Mac
- Why Linux Isn't Mainstream, Used PowerBooks a Poor Value, the iMac G3 Legacy, and More, Dan Knight, Low End Mac Mailbag, 08.19. Also installing Leopard on a PowerPC Mac from an Intel installer, NeoOffice opens WordPerfect files, emulating old Macs, and where to download an iMac manual.
- What's the Best Mac OS for Your iBook, PowerBook, or MacBook?, Charles W. Moore, 'Book Value, 08.19. Tips on choosing the best OS for your PowerBook 500 Series or newer Mac notebook.
- Best iMac G4 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.19. Used 15" 700 MHz CD-RW, $279; 800 Combo, $300; 1 GHz $390; 17" 800 MHz SD, $439; 1.25 GHz, $449; 20", $569.
- Best 15" MacBook Pro Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.19. Used 1.83 GHz Core Duo, $999; 2.16, $1,125; new, 2.2, $1,450 after rebate; refurb 2.4, $1,649; 2.5, $1,999; 2.6, $2,299; rebates on new.
- Best Mac OS X 10.0-10.3 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.19. Mac OS X 10.0.3, $30; 10.1, $20; 10.2, $60; 10.3 CD, $70; DVD, $90; 10.1 Server, unlimited users, $72; 10.3 Server, unlimited, $130.
- Mac of the Day: Outbound Laptop and Notebook, Sep. 1989 - The best known among the early Mac clones.
- List of the Day: Mac Pro List is for those using a Mac Pro.
- August 20 in LEM history: 98: Unplanned obsolescence - 99: Open Link Policy - 01: Video editing on low end Macs - Picking a PCI video card - 02: iTunes 3 review - 04: Bad RAM can crash your Mac - Dual-core G4s coming - 07: White iBooks still a good bet? - VMware Fusion good for fusing Windows with OS X - Restoring PowerBook batteries
- Snow Leopard, Windows 7, Midori, and the End of Windows, Frank Fox, Stop the Noiz, 08.18. A look at some of the technologies planned for Mac OS X 10.6, Windows 7, and Midori, Microsoft's future OS that could be the end of Windows.
- Using Low End Macs for Internet Radio, Gordon R. Brown, My Turn, 08.18. When the local public radio station moved classical music to HD radio, it was time to find another way to listen. An old iMac with iTunes solved the problem.
- PCs Not Like Macs, Claris Home Page Fan, iMac G4 Upgrade Tips, iBook Prices, and More, Dan Knight, Low End Mac Mailbag, 08.18. Also using PC3200 RAM in a Mirror Drive Door G4, cloning the classic Mac OS to a new hard drive, and thoughts on a Windows App Store.
- REALbasic Growing to Include Cocoa, Mobile, and Web Development, Rick Lawson, Pioneers in Mac Development, 08.18. REALbasic is a cross platform development tool for Mac, Windows, and Linux. The company is working on expanding that to the Web, mobile devices, and the Mac's Cocoa.
- Best Mac mini Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.18. Used 1.25 GHz G4 SD, $549; 1.42 Combo, $409; new 1.83 Core2 Combo, $569 after rebate; 2.0 SD, $769 after rebate.
- Best 12" PowerBook G4 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.18. Used 867 MHz Combo, no APX, $490; 1 GHz SuperDrive, $625; 1.33 GHz, $611; 1.5 GHz SD w/o APX, $660; w/APX, $675.
- Resetting the iPod's Display Language When You Don't Know the Language It's Using, Charles W. Moore, Miscellaneous Ramblings, 08.18. If you've ever set your iPod's language to one you can't read, there is a way to reset it.
- iPod 'Missing Manual' Grows but Drops Coverage of Older iPods, Charles W. Moore, Miscellaneous Ramblings, 08.18. The 6th edition of iPod: The Missing Manual has extensive coverage of all the current iPod models, but at the cost of dropping coverage of all earlier models.
- Best Apple TV Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 08.18. Refurb 40 GB Apple TV, $199; new, $224; refurb 160 GB, $279; new, $322 - prices include free ground shipping.
- More links in our archive.
About LEM | Support | Usage | Privacy | Contacts
Have a question?
Ask an expert!
Navigation
Used Mac Dealers
Apple History
Best Used Macs
Video Cards
Email Lists
InfoMac's Low
End Mac Forum
Favorite Sites
MacSurfer
MacMinute
MacInTouch
MyAppleMenu
InfoMac
Macs Only!
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
RetroMacCast
PB Central
MacWindows
The Vintage Mac
Museum
DealMac
DealsOnTheWeb
Mac2Sell
ramseeker
Mac Driver Museum
JAG's House
System
6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End
Mac FAQ
Abandonware
Petition
Mac vs. PC Info
Affiliates
The Apple
Store
Mac
Connection
MacMall
TechRestore
MacResQ
ExperCom
Crucial
Memory
batteries.com
Advertise
