Search LEM
Donate · Amazon.com · MacResQ · Advertise Other Cobweb sites: Low End Living · Reformed.net

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Darwin Source Less Than Open

- 2001.05.30

In Just for Fun, Linus Torvalds' recent memoir of the early days of Linux, Torvalds recounts meeting Steve Jobs and Apple technical chief Avie Tevanian.

"Basically, Jobs started off by telling me that on the desktop there were just two players, Microsoft and Apple, and that he thought the best thing I could do for Linux was to get in bed with Apple and try to get the open source people behind Mac OS X," Torvalds writes.

"Jobs made a big point of the fact that Mach's low-level kernel is open source. He sort of played down the flaw in the setup: Who cares if the basic operating system . . . is open source if you then have the Mac layer on top, which is not open source?"

Well, no one says the Mac layer has to be open, but on the other hand - if OS X is built on a free Unix, does Apple have an obligation to return something substantial to the open source community?

Legally, no, and let's face it - the goals of Apple and the Linux folks are mutually exclusive. Apple says "We have the neat stuff. Come buy it from us." Linux says "You can build the neat stuff yourself. Let us help."

However, you can argue that there's a moral obligation on Apple's part. Mach and Unix are why OS X is so stable, so Apple is profiting from open source software.

That's okay: after all, there are a number of companies profiting (or attempting to profit) from the sale of Linux. However, they don't keep big chunks of their code under lock and key.

And Apple? Apple provides the plumbing for OS X in the form of "Darwin," which is released under the company's own version of an open source license.

However, Darwin is flawed as open source. A recent posting on penguinppc.org points out, "Apple does not fully release the Darwin source into the public source. Key drivers are left out, and some workarounds for chip bugs are pulled before the public versions are made available."

The point? Penguinppc.org concludes "This keeps Linux developers from using the Darwin source as a reference."

If true, this strikes me as a shot directly at the open source folks. You can make a pretty good case for keeping the "Mac part" of OS X private: what case can you make for taking from open source and then not providing the bare minimum needed to get open source running on your hardware?

Apple is not likely to listen to such arguments, anymore than it is likely to see the foolishness of suppressing the user groups that distributed older versions of its software, but it makes the company's continuing claim to somehow being hipper, better than the rest (read: Wintel) nothing more than advertising.

<back to the original article>

Share your perspective on the Mac by emailing with "My Turn" as your subject.

Recent My Turn articles

• Upgrading a Digital Audio G4 to work better in Leopard, 06.02. In its original configuration, the dual 533 MHz Power Mac G4 was slow with Mac OS X 10.5, but add the right upgrades, and it runs Leopard quite nicely.
• My 4 favorite PowerBooks, 05.28. The PowerBook 150 has a big screen for a vintage PowerBook, the 165c has color, the 100 is diminutive, and Lombard has USB and a great keyboard.
• Upgraded Quadra a great server for vintage Mac networking, 05.21. The compact Quadra 610 runs quietly, and with a PowerPC upgrade, it rockets past regular 68040 Macs.
• More in the My Turn index.

Recent Content on Low End Mac

• Mac Pro overclocking, Windependence with Darwine, Blu-ray for Macs, and more, Mac News Review, 07.04. Also more on running Leopard on non-Apple hardware, Ubuntu on a Mac mini, the first autofocus webcam with Zeiss optics for Macs, and more.
• Wouldn't life be great with an iSlate?, John Hatchett, Recycled Computing, 07.04. PDAs and smartphones are too small for some tasks, full-fledged Tablet PCs are overkill, and ebook readers are too limited. Apple has the tech to own this niche.
• Mac of the Day: Original iMac G3/233, Aug. 98 - The Bondi blue wonder that bounced Apple back to profitability and into the public eye.
• List of the Day: Mac Pro List is for those using a Mac Pro.
  
• The Macintosh Portable started a notebook revolution, Carl Nygren, Classic Macs in the Intel Age, 07.03. Before Apple introduced the Mac Portable, notebook computers were text-based and ran MS-DOS. Ever since, graphical interfaces have been the norm for laptops.
• More links in our archive.

Entire Low End Mac site copyright ©1997-2008 by Cobweb Publishing, Inc., unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved. Advice presented in good faith, but what works for one may not work for all. Please report errors to the webmaster.
  LINKS: We allow and encourage links to any public page as long as the linked page does not appear within a frame that prevents bookmarking it.
  Access our RSS news feed at http://lowendmac.com/feed.xml.
  Email may be published at our discretion; email addresses will not be published without permission. If you prefer your message not be published, mark it "not for publication." Letters may be edited for length, context, and to match house style.
  PRIVACY: We don't collect personal information unless you explicitly provide it. For more details, see our Terms of Use.
  Low End Mac is an independent publication and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Apple Computer. Apple, the Apple logo, Macintosh, iBook, iMac, eMac, iPod, and PowerBook are registered trademarks of Apple Computer, Inc. Additional company and product names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are hereby acknowledged.