Intel: Thinking Different

On the Mac side of the fence, we all know the processors found in the Power Mac G3, the PowerBook G3, and in G3 upgrades in a host of older Macs are up to twice as fast as Intel's Pentium II processor.

But did you also know that Intel has a long history of intentionally crippling chips?

Birth of the PC

It all began with the 8088. Intel had leveraged it's 8-bit 8080 and 8085 designs into a 16-bit CPU, the 8086. The new chip had a 16-bit data path, 16-bit registers, and could address 16 64KB banks of memory. In all respects, the 8086 was a worthy successor.

But the world was full of 8-bit motherboards and peripherals, so Intel created a version of the 8086 for an 8-bit bus. And it was the crippled 8088 CPU that IBM and almost every cloner chose, not the more efficient 8086.

Jump ahead to the late 1980s. Intel introduced the 80386, a 32-bit CPU with 32-bit registers and a 32-bit bus. Then, because other companies were allowed to make the 80286, Intel decided to kill that market with the 80386SX, a 32-bit CPU on a 16-bit bus. Every benchmark showed it the equal of the less expensive 80286, but the 80386SX name and Intel brand sold it.

Next generation Intel built the floating point unit (FPU) into the CPU. For number crunching, the 80486 ran circles around the 80386. And, to reach a cheaper market and stave of CPU competitors, Intel created the 80486SX: essentially the same chip but with the FPU disabled. Of course, you could supplement this with the 80487SX, an 80486 with only the FPU enabled.

Somehow Intel pulled it off. In fact, I sometimes wonder if this wasn't part of the reason for the Motorola 68LC040, essentially an FPU-free version of the 68040.

Fast Forward

Why shouldn't history repeat itself? This year Intel did it again, taking the mighty Pentium II and removing the cache (which is essential for top performance). The new chip is named Celeron, which brings to mind speed. It's cheap, but it isn't fast. (A common nickname is Deceleron.) Intel designed it that way.

But manufacturers balked, saying Intel had gone too far. So the next generation will have a 128KB built-in cache. And Intel should be able to justify a higher price.

Still, Intel has intentionally crippled another CPU.

But to show it can move forward, Intel has announced the Pentium II Xeon (see Intel's Xeon to tip price scales). Where the Pentium II has a 512 KB 02.1 cache, Xeon runs a 01.1 cache of 512 KB, 1 MB, or 2 MB. Intel is promoting Xeon for servers, where up to eight 400 MHz CPUs can share a 100 MHz bus and run flat out.

Thinking Different

The same thing hasn't happened in the PowerPC world. It simply didn't occur to the PowerPC partners to intentional cripple a CPU. The 601 was followed by the equally powerful 603* and the more powerful 604. These became the 603e and 604e. The 603e has evolved into the 740 and 750, commonly called the G3 - the processor TV watchers know is twice as fast as the Pentium II.** And next year we'll see G4, which should be significantly more powerful than the 604e and the G3.

Apple, Motorola, and IBM haven't resorted to making stripped down chips. Much easier to make one or two chips that aren't intentionally crippled than a family including Celeron, Pentium, Pentium MMX, Pentium Pro, Pentium II, and Pentium II Xeon.

And it doesn't confuse the consumer nearly as much to choose between three different G3 speeds than between several different CPUs, each available at multiple speeds.

Final Outcome

What's completely ludicrous is that Intel is willing to cut margins on the cheap chips to gain market share - then inflate the price of Xeon to make up for it.

The Xeon is a 400 MHz CPU with a 400 MHz cache. Pricey. With a 512 KB cache, cost is estimated at $1,124 (quantity 1,000). Add $175 to that and you've got an iMac - the whole computer. And you don't have to buy 1,000 iMacs to get this price.

With 1 MB cache, Xeon is a $2,836 chip. That's about $100 more than the G3/300 desktop, but all you're getting is a single Xeon CPU. Perhaps a more fair comparison to the Xeon is a G3/300 daughter card with 1 MB 01.1 cache. But those start at about $1,700 - over $1,100 less than Xeon.

Top of the heap, the Xeon will be available with a 2 MB cache. Projected price, quantity 1,000, is $4,489. That'd buy three iMacs, a printer, and a scanner. Or nine of the least expensive G3 upgrade cards. Or a fully decked out G3/300 system.

Intel wants that much money for a single CPU.

I guess they do know how to think different.

* Some may argue that the first generation 603-based Macs were less powerful than the 601-based Macs that preceded them. And they'd be right. The system architecture of the Performa 6200 and 6300 was horrendous, but the 603 processor itself matches 601 performance.

 

** The key difference between the PPC 740 and 750 is that the 740 has no built-in cache support, while the 750 supports both inline and backside caches.

Dan Knight has been using Macs since 1986, sold Macs for several years, supported them for many more years, and has been publishing Low End Mac since April 1997. If you find Dan's articles helpful, please consider making a donation to his tip jar.

Recent Mac Musings

• No High Definition iTunes Video for You, 11.19. The October 2008 MacBooks are preventing users from viewing some high-def iTunes content from being viewed on their external displays. Poor form!
• Anticipating Macworld: Nehalem, Snow Leopard, and Updated Desktops, 11.18. Intel's Core i7 CPU has to make it way into the next Mac Pro, nVidia GeForce graphics will drive the iMac and Mac mini, and 'Snow Tiger' will unleash the animal within.
• One Used Mac Can Make a Difference, 11.12. Instead of scrapping out old Macs for raw materials, what if the Mac community worked to restore them and give them away to those with no computers?
• A Brief History of Portable Computing: From Dynabook to Netbooks, 11.06. 40 years ago Alan Kay dreamt of a two pound handheld computer. Portables have made a lot of changes since 1981, but haven't yet matched the Dynabook.
• More in the Mac Musings index.

Links for the Day

• Mac of the Day: 14" iBook G3/600 MHz, Jan. 2002 - The first 14" iBook ran at a comfortable 600 MHz.
• Group of the Day: Mac OS 9 List covers Mac OS 9 as both a freestanding OS and as Classic mode in OS X.
  
• December 1 in LEM history: 99: Monitor dot pitch - 00: Macs for new users - Everybody wants to use iMacs - Career options - 03: Pfinder: Panther-like Finder for legacy Macs - 04: Why I use an eMac, iBook, and Power Mac - ThinkFree Office - MacLink Plus 15 - 05: PowerBook 190 still a great laptop - Eudora, the Mac's most powerful email client - 06: Core 2 'Books cooler and faster

Recent Content on Low End Mac

• The Very Best Macs: Sometimes Apple Just Nails It, Andrew J Fishkin, Best Tools for the Job, 12.01. Apple has produced lots of good Macs, a few dogs, and some 'best of breed' models that stand apart from the pack.
• Apple Could Buy Dell, and Linux Is No Threat to Mac OS X, Charles W. Moore, Miscellaneous Ramblings, 12.01. Apple has the cash to buy Dell outright, and the idea has some merit. Also, why Linux still isn't ready to displace the Mac OS.
• Will Snow Leopard Support Some PowerPC Macs?, Simon Royal, Mac Spectrum, 11.26. It just doesn't make sense that Apple would ship a new OS that won't support Macs sold less than three years ago.
• From Ubuntu to OS X, Picking the Right Mac, an Aluminum Mouse Pad, and More, Mac News Review, 11.26. Also changes in Apple culture, OWC rebates on Hitachi drives, Clone X clones OS X, and LaCie SilverKeeper updated for OS X 10.5.5.
• Apple Retail Will Break Records This Christmas, Tim Nash, Taking Back the Market, 11.26. "Despite all the economic problems, Apple Retail can look forward to another successful quarter with sales maybe breaking through $2 billion...."
• iPhone 2.2 Software Update Released and Jailbroken, Advent Calendars for Your iPhone, and More, iNews Review, 11.26. Also making Street View work on the iPod touch, BlackBerry Storm questions answered, Microsoft's forthcoming phone, eco-friendly cases, and more.
• MacBook Slowdown without Battery, DisplayLink and DRM, 256 GB SSD, MagSafe Solutions, and More, The 'Book Review, 11.26. Also Mac netbook prospects, laptop cooling table with 2 fans, solar notebook bag, hard shell cases for unibody 'Books, bargain 'Books from $500 to $2,299, and more.
• Old Macs in the New Economy, John Hatchett, Recycled Computing, 11.25. "We are the kings of making our computers last, last, and last some more."
• Virtualization Shootout: VirtualBox 2 vs. VMWare Fusion 2, Kev Kitchens, Kitchens Sync, 11.25. VirtualBox is aimed at a different audience than Fusion and Parallels. While it works well, the typical desktop user will probably prefer Fusion.
• Software to Keep Your MacBook Cool, Phil Herlihy, The Usefulness Equation, 11.25. Heat is the enemy of long hardware life. Two programs to keep your MacBook running cooler.
• Another Way to Run WeatherBug, Aspire One Runs OS X, 17" MacBook Pro Hi-res Display, and More, Charles W. Moore, Miscellaneous Ramblings, 11.25. Also finding that 'just right' notebook computer, car, or truck.
• More links in our archive.

Recent Deals

• Best iPod nano Deals, 12.01. Refurb 3G/4 GB, $79; new, $105; refurb 8 GB, $99; new, $115; 3G/8 GB, $134; 16 GB, $174. Prices include ground shipping.
• Best 12" PowerBook G4 Deals, 12.01. Used 1.5 GHz SuperDrive, $481/C$599 plus shipping.
• Best Mac Pro Deals, 12.01. Used 3.0 GHz 4-core, $2,102; new 2.66 GHz 4-core, $1,949 after rebate; 2.8 4-core, $2,099 a/r; 8-core, $2,515 a/r; 3.0 $3,320 a/r; 3.2, $4,099 a/r.
• Best MacBook Deals, 11.26. Used 1.83 GHz, $595; 2.0 SD, $660; refurb 2.1 GHz, $949; 2.4, $999; black, $1,099; new 2.1, $869 after rebate; 2.4, $1,150 a/r; black, $1,194 a/r; more.
• Best iPod touch Deals, 11.26. Used 1G/8 GB, $160; refurb, $179; new, $198; used 16, $200; refurb, $219; refurb 32, $319; new, $340; 2G/8 GB, $219; 16, $289; 32, $379.
• Best Power Mac G5 Deals, 11.26. Used 1.6 GHz single, $450; 1.8, $499; dual, $600, 2.0, $800; 2.3, $816; dual-core, $1,000; 2.5 dual, $1,000; 2.7, $1,050; 2.5 Quad, $1,400.
• Best MacBook Deals, 11.26. Used 1.83 GHz, $595; 2.0 SD, $660; refurb 2.1 GHz, $949; 2.4, $999; black, $1,099; new 2.1, $869 after rebate; 2.4, $1,150 a/r; black, $1,194 a/r; more.
• Best Mac mini Deals, 11.25. Used 1.42 GHz G4 Combo, $429; 1.66 GHz Core Duo, $449; 1.83, SuperDrive $629; new 1.83 Core 2 Combo, $570 shipped; 2.0 SD, $760 shipped.
• Best 15" PowerBook G4 Deals, 11.25. Used 1.67 GHz SuperDrive, $539; hi-res, $800. Shipping additional.
• Best Time Capsule and AirPort Deals, 11.25. Refurb 500 GB Time Capsule, $249; new, $281; refurb 1 TB, $419; new, $462; AirPort Extreme Base Station, $159; Express, $60.
• More deals in our archive.

About LEM | Support | Usage | Privacy | Contacts

Entire Low End Mac website copyright ©1997-2008 by Cobweb Publishing, Inc., unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved. Advice presented in good faith, but what works for one may not work for all. Please report errors to .
  LINKS: We allow and encourage links to any public page as long as the linked page does not appear within a frame that prevents bookmarking it.
  Access our RSS news feed at http://lowendmac.com/feed.xml.
  Email may be published at our discretion; email addresses will not be published without permission, and we will encrypt them in hopes of avoiding spammers. If you prefer your message not be published, mark it "not for publication." Letters may be edited for length, context, and to match house style.
  PRIVACY: We don't collect personal information unless you explicitly provide it. For more details, see our Terms of Use.
  Low End Mac is an independent publication and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Apple Inc. Apple, the Apple logo, Macintosh, iBook, iMac, eMac, iPod, iPhone, PowerBook, MacBook, MagSafe, Mac Pro, Apple TV, and AirPort are registered trademarks of Apple Inc. Additional company and product names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are hereby acknowledged.