Mac Musings
Windows XP Is Faster, but Mac OS X Is Superior in Many Ways
Dan Knight - 2008.04.11 - Tip Jar
Scott Hansen, an artist and musician in San Francisco, has provided the most honest assessment of the differences between Macs and Windows PCs that I've read, and his conclusions are sure to disappoint some Mac partisans.
Hansen uses Photoshop a lot and has been migrating from Windows XP to Mac OS X. He states right up front that he is "totally in love" with OS X - but there are areas where Windows is better.
The Mac is visually superior, creating a more enjoyable user experience. After using the Mac, Hansen states that he is disappointed every time he goes back to Windows - it's that big a difference. He says, "the beauty and simplicity of the OS X interface is an incredible achievement." And, of course, things tend to "just work" on the Mac, making it a less frustrating user experience.
His second point is that Mac OS X is much more stable than Windows when using Photoshop. He complains that working with Photoshop "in Windows is wrought with errors, bugs, crashes, and lost work." And it's not just one particular machine - this has been his constant experience over the years with Windows XP. By comparison, he says that Photoshop on the Mac has never crashed or misbehaved.
His third point is one some Mac lovers won't like hearing: For raw performance, Windows XP beats Mac OS X. Hansen has run both operating systems on the same hardware, his own optimized Photoshop system with a 4.2 GHz (overclocked) Core 2 Extreme Quad Core CPU, and XP wins every speed comparison. He speculates that this is because OS X has more overhead - more tasks running in the background.
This is something we've discussed here in the past: Every operating system has to make tradeoffs, has to find its own balance point. You can go for maximum speed, maximum ease of use, maximum number of features, maximum interface smoothness, maximum security, etc. But a smooth interface and robust multitasking uses computing power, so you're sacrificing some speed for a better experience. That's the choice the Mac OS has always made by putting the user experience first.
Losing out to Windows in Photoshop is a change from the PowerPC past, when Steve Jobs would compare a Mac with a Windows PC running a huge macro script in Photoshop during his keynote, and the Mac would blow the PC away. Now that we're all using the same Intel Core 2 processors, the overhead of OS X gives Windows XP an advantage in terms of raw computing power applied to the current application. (No word on whether this is still the case with Vista, which most Windows users wish had never been invented. Hansen is coming to OS X from XP, not Vista.)
"the myriad superiorities of the OS X experience far outweigh any performance benefit you might realize within XP."
However, while we have lost bragging rights for Photoshop performance, Hansen notes that "the myriad superiorities of the OS X experience far outweigh any performance benefit you might realize within XP." Those are words Apple should put on billboards.
In the end, Hansen declares it a tie between Windows XP and Mac OS X. Each has strengths and weaknesses. Of course, that's because he's comparing Windows XP with OS X. In Hansen's own words, Vista sucks. He calls it "a complete and utter disaster" and suggests it prefaces Windows' eventual and inevitable decline.
And what is he buying? A MacBook Pro is his choice as his default
computer. He's putting his money where it will give him the best
computing experience, and that's the Mac platform hands down.
Join us on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter.
Dan Knight has been using Macs since 1986, sold Macs for several years, supported them for many more years, and has been publishing Low End Mac since April 1997. If you find Dan's articles helpful, please consider making a donation to his tip jar.
Recent articles by Dan Knight
- Kill Caps Lock, but Leave the Rest of My Keyboard Alone (Mostly), 2012.02.03. It's too easy to hit Caps Lock by accident, but why change a keyboard layout that billions of users are comfortable with?
- Is This RIM's Macintosh Moment?, 2012.01.25. In 1996, Apple was in dire straits, but Steve Jobs redefined the company. Now it's do or die time for RIM.
- Saying Good-bye to Inkjet Printers, 2012.01.18. Apple has discontinued its $100 printer rebates, but even a free inkjet printer is false economy.
- More in the Mac Musings index.
Links for the Day
- Mac of the Day: Dynamac, introduced 1987.02. This AC-only portable has a backlit electroluminescent screen.
- February 3 in LEM history: 1998: Apple and CompUSA - 2001: Vinyl to disc - 2003: Apple has always been a significant player - Upgrading a Power Mac G4 - Making a bootable OS X CD - 2005: Apple's future is with the consumer market - 2006: Browsers for the Classic Mac OS - Microsoft's monopoly makes it slow and vulnerable
- Support Low End Mac
Recent Content on Low End Mac
- Does iOS Doom the Mac?, Apple Again #1 Smartphone Vendor, Massive 16 iPad Charger, and More, iOS News Review, 2012.02.03. Also Sleipnir browser lets you share links locally, iPro brings Schneider lenses to iPhone 4, and more.
- Time to End 13" MacBook Pro?, Refurb MacBook Air from $699, Enable TRIM in OS X, and More, The 'Book Review, 2012.02.03. Also Auro Pro Express SSD upgrades for 2010/11 MacBook Air, Sleipnir browser syncs bookmarks with iOS, Prey laptop recovery tool, and more.
- Apple Refurbs a Great Deal, iOSificiation a Fundamental Shift for Apple, and More, Mac News Review, 2012.02.03. Also IT workers embracing Apple, battery-free wireless mouse, freeware alternatives to commercial apps, and more.
- 25 Years of AppleShare Networking, Low End Mac Round Table, 2012.02.02. Macs have always had built-in networking, but Apple didn't have server software for Macs until 1987.
- Disk Expert Helps You Find and Delete or Archive Your Biggest Files, Steve Watkins, The Practical Mac, 2012.02.02. If your hard drive, flash drive, or SSD is filling up, Disk Expert can help pinpoint the biggest files, which you may be able to delete or archive.
- Tiger or Leopard for PowerPC Macs? Does It Matter Anymore?, Simon Royal, Mac Spectrum, 2012.01.31. Does it really matter whether you run OS X 10.4 Tiger or 10.5 Leopard on your increasingly left-behind PowerPC Macs?
- MacBook Air vs. MacBook Pro, Looking for a Vertical MacBook Stand, and SE/30 Internet Tips, Charles W. Moore, Charles Moore's Mailbag, 2012.01.31. Whether a MacBook Air makes as much sense as a MacBook Pro, finding a vertical stand for a MacBook, and tips for getting an SE/30 on the Internet.
- More links in our archive.
Recent Deals
- Best iPad Deals
- Best Classic Mac OS Deals
- Best Apple TV Deals
- Best 15" MacBook Pro Deals
- Best Power Mac G4 Deals
- Best Mac OS X 10.6 Deals
- Best MacBook Deals
- Best Time Capsule Deals
- Best 17" PowerBook G4 Deals
- More deals in our archive.
About LEM Support Usage Privacy Contact
Follow
Low End Mac on Twitter
Join Low End Mac
on Facebook
Low End Mac Reader Specials
TypeStyler 11 is now in the Mac App Store!! -- Special Introductory Price of $59.95!! -- To Buy From The Mac App Store Click Here Now!! Or buy direct
from Strider Software.
Don't install Parallels to play poker online! Poker Mac will show you how to download and install a native Mac poker and Mac Casino applications in minutes.
Favorite Sites
MacSurfer
Cult of Mac
Shrine of Apple
MacInTouch
MyAppleMenu
InfoMac
The Mac Observer
Accelerate Your Mac
RetroMacCast
PB Central
MacWindows
The Vintage Mac Museum
DealMac
Deal Brothers
Mac2Sell
Mac Driver Museum
JAG's House
System 6 Heaven
System 7 Today
the pickle's Low-End Mac FAQ
Affiliates
Amazon.com
The Apple Store
The iTunes Store
PC Connection Express
GainSaver
Parallels Desktop for Mac
eBay
