Low End Mac Reader Specials

TypeStyler For Mac OS X is Now Shipping! Download The Free Fully Functional 60 Day Tryout at www.typestyler.com

Don't install Parallels to play poker online! Poker Mac will show you how to download and install a native Mac poker application such as Full Tilt Poker Mac.

Laptop Hardware Provided by TechRestore - Overnight Mac & iPod Repairs.

Compare products like desktop computers, apple laptops, apple macs, and LCD Monitors side by side! All the information and reviews to make the best purchasing decision for new mobile phones, sat nav systems, or MP3 players. The Ciao online shopping community makes searching products easy for you.

The Efficient Mac User

How Consumer Reports Could Compare Macs Fairly

- 2005.11.23 - Tip Jar

Many Low End Mac readers have responded to last week's article on how badly Consumer Reports (CR) handles Macintosh computers in their holiday gift buying guide. There has been a lot of agreement and affirmation, and it's great to see that the word is getting out about the shortcomings of CR's ratings.

A few readers mentioned that they hoped for CR-style ratings charts in my article, but they were disappointed not to find them. I considered including charts with the original article, but I decided not to because I didn't have access to the data for all of the machines I wanted to include.

On further consideration (and after discussion with the editors at Low End Mac), I decided to follow-up with some Consumer Reports-style ratings charts that compare Apple's machines appropriately and fairly.

These charts show how CR could have compared Apple's computers with Windows PCs. They were created by the author, adpted from CR's data, and are provided as an example only and are not intended to replace CR's copyrighted material.

Disclaimer: The original CR data used to generate the charts below (on pages 36 & 37 of the December 2005 issue, Vol. 70 No. 12) only included a total of three Macintosh desktop computers and two Macintosh laptops. Thus, the four additional Macintosh machines shown below include ratings data that is approximated and not a product of CR's testing (or any other formal testing).

If you read the first article, you'll know that I had two primary complaints about the CR ratings charts. First, they segregated the Macs into a Macintosh "ghetto" so that point-by-point comparison was difficult or impossible. Second, they included a minimal number of Macintosh systems, in the process suggesting that the Apple line either didn't have machines that would fit into their categories or inferring that one system or another was worse than it purports to be.

Here, then, is my version of a good Desktop System ratings chart. Notice that I have added one of the Power Mac G5 systems to the "workhorse" category. (Click on the these charts to see the full-sized originals.)

Ranking Key:

EX = excellent

VG = very good

GD = good

FR = fair

PR = poor

Notes in the ratings:

Systems are ranked by their overall scores. The best that I can tell is that these are determined by the test results; therefore, the score and test results for the Power Mac G5 system (line 10) are approximated using the system specs and a comparison to the non-Macintosh machines on the chart.

USB ports listed do not include the two USB 1.1 ports available on Apple keyboards, which are supplied with all Macintosh systems listed except the Mac mini.

Warranty presents an interesting rating when it comes to the Apple machines, since CR ranks the Apple warranty as "Good" while they consistently give Apple very high marks for customer service and support.

Price is approximated for the system only, with the exception of the iMac and eMac, which both include built-in displays. Please note that the price for the Mac mini has been adjusted from CR's approximation, since they added in $78 for mouse and keyboard, which are not a part of the "system only" described.

Likewise, here is an adjusted version of the Laptop Computers ratings chart. This time you'll notice that I've added three additional Macintosh 'Books into the mix.

Ranking key is the same for both charts.

Notes on the ratings:

Again, systems are ranked by their overall scores. As with the desktops, I approximated results for the additional included machines: the 12" iBook (line 2), the 17" PowerBook (line 9), and the 12" PowerBook (line 13). This time, however, my approximations were based on comparisons to other non-Macintosh machines and to the Macs that were ranked.

Note also that the listings (taken from CR) show an older model for the 15" PowerBook, which now has a better screen resolution for the same price. (I'll grant that this is likely the case for many of the systems listed because of CR's lead time.)

As you can see, when placed side-by-side, the Macintosh systems hold their own and, in many cases, rise to the top for performance, features, and overall ranking. Consumer Reports truly ought to develop a more comprehensive and fair cross-platform rating system, especially given the rising popularity of the Macintosh platform.

If all other considerations are truly equal, CR should give consumers a clear picture of how Macs compare to their Windows PC counterparts.

One more conclusion that I arrived at through this exercise: CPU speed is fairly useless for determining the functionality of a machine. I know that Apple proponents (and Apple spokespeople) have been claiming this for years, but a close look at these charts shows it demonstrably. Anytime you can have 3 GHz, 1.8 GHz, and 1.67 GHz machines all performing equally with something as taxing as multimedia (see "Multimedia Laptops"), you know there is a disparity. This is not just a difference from one chip maker to another, either - notice the number of variations made by Intel but ranked approximately the same for speed and performance. Chip speed is truly no longer a predictor of performance.

Once again, I hope this is helpful in guiding your holiday shopping. Shop smart!

If you find Ed's articles helpful, please consider making a donation to his tip jar.

Recent Efficient Mac User articles

Apple Hopes for 2009, 12.24. Things I'd like to see Apple do in the coming year.
Think bull: Why the shuttering of Think Secret is no big deal, 01.04. Apple and Ciarelli have reached a mutually satisfactory agreement, and journalism is not at stake here.
Wishes for 2008: Apple TV content, task management for the iPhone, and the MacBook mini, 12.13. Apple TV is being held back due to limited content, the iPhone needs solid task management, and it's time for Apple to redefine the ultra-portable notebook market.
Why I won't be getting an iPhone this year, 05.21. The iPhone is likely to have early problems, prices are bound to come down, and the current service contract won't allow the switch until January 2008.
More in the Efficient Mac User index.

Links for the Day

Mac of the Day: Mac mini Core Solo, Feb. 2006 - The only Mac to use a Core Solo CPU, this model ran at 1.5 GHz, has integrated graphics, and includes a Combo drive
Group of the Day: SuperMacs is for those using Umax SuperMac clones.
November 24 in LEM history: 98: Microsoft's heavy hand - 00: Looking at the iMac - 04: The best Mac for the holidays - Picking the right replacement for a dead mouse - Better battery for 15" AlBook
Support Low End Mac

Recent Deals

Best G4 iMac Deals, 11.24. Used 15" 700 MHz CD-RW, $150; 800 MHz Combo, $229; 1 GHz, $289; 17" 1.25 GHz, $200; 20" 1.25 GHz, $509.
Best MacBook Air Deals, 11.24. Used from $899; refurb from $1,099; new 1.6 GHz/120 HD, $1,150 after rebate; 1.8/64 SSD, $1,150 a/r; 1.86/128 SSD, $1,350 a/r; 2.13/128 SSD, $1,694 a/r.
Best PowerBook G3 Deals, 11.24. Used 233 MHz WallStreet, $75; 266 MHz, $160; 400 MHz Lombard, $199; 400 MHz Pismo, $289; 500 MHz, $350.
Best 12" PowerBook G4 Deals, 11.23. Used 867 MHz SuperDrive, $348; 1 GHz Combo, $379; SD, $519; 1.33 GHz, $529; 1.5 GHz Combo, $549; SuperDrive, $609.
Best Mac Pro Deals, 11.23. Used 2.66 GHz 4-core, $1,300; 3.0 4-core. $1,919; refurb 2.66 4-core Nehalem, $2,149; 2.93, $2,549; 2.93 8-core, $4,999; new 2.26 8-core, $2,290.
Best Time Capsule and AirPort Deals, 11.23. Used 802.11g AirPort Extreme, $49; 500 GB Time Capsule, $150; new, $190; 1 TB dual-band, $280; 2 TB, $469; 802.11n AirPort Extreme, $170.
Best eMac Deals, 11.18. Used 1 GHz Combo, $100; SuperDrive, $269; 1.25 GHz Combo, $119; SD, $319; 1.42 GHz Combo, $289; SD, $498.
Best Mac OS X 10.6 and Mac Box Set Deals, 11.18. "Snow Leopard", single user, $25; 5 users, $45; Mac Box Set, single user, $139; 5 users, $180; Server, $414. Shipping included.
Best Xserve Deals, 11.18. Used 1 GHz dual G4, $649; 2.3 dual G5, $795; 3.0 4-core Xeon, $1,899; refurb 2.26 4-core, $2,499; new, $2,888; refurb 8-core, $2,999; new, $3,449; more.
More deals in our archive.

About LEM | Support | Usage | Privacy | Contacts

The Efficient Mac User articles copyright ©2005-08 by Ed Eubanks. Entire Low End Mac website copyright ©1997-2009 by Cobweb Publishing, Inc., unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved. Advice presented in good faith, but what works for one may not work for all. Please report errors to .
LINKS: We allow and encourage links to any public page as long as the linked page does not appear within a frame that prevents bookmarking it.
Access our RSS news feed at http://lowendmac.com/feed.xml.
Email may be published at our discretion; email addresses will not be published without permission, and we will encrypt them in hopes of avoiding spammers. If you prefer your message not be published, mark it "not for publication." Letters may be edited for length, context, and to match house style.
PRIVACY: We don't collect personal information unless you explicitly provide it. For more details, see our Terms of Use.
Low End Mac is an independent publication and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Apple Inc. Apple, the Apple logo, Macintosh, iBook, iMac, eMac, iPod, iPhone, PowerBook, MacBook, MagSafe, Mac Pro, Apple TV, and AirPort are registered trademarks of Apple Inc. Additional company and product names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are hereby acknowledged.