Gmail and Hotmail Are Nice, but Isn't It Time for Apple to Offer Free Webmail Again?

- 2006.11.02

Lately I've been using a Gmail account for most of my email. I find that Gmail has an elegant, easy to use interface that works well on pretty much any computer, as well as a good capacity for storage of old emails (2 GB and counting).

I also love the integration with your computer via the Gmail notifier (available for both Windows and Mac OS X). The OS X version goes in your menu bar, near the volume control icon and spotlight icon. It plays a sound when new mail arrives, and allows you to create a new mail message, see your inbox, or read new mail via a dropdown menu. This kind of integration is what I've always wanted from webmail, and Google has provided it.

Hotmail, on the other hand, has for the past couple years been relatively stagnant. Its user interface was very clumsy and confusing.

For instance, in order to read a message, you would click on the sender, rather than the title of the message when viewing it in your inbox. I still can't figure out how the people at Microsoft came up with that - it's the last way I can think of for selecting email messages to read.

Also, attaching a file was confusing in the sense that once a file is selected, the 'OK' button is at the top of the screen!

Windows Live Mail

Microsoft thinks it can do better. Windows Live Mail, its next-generation Hotmail webmail interface, aims to be more Outlook- and Windows-like than the previous version of Hotmail.

I was initially not too interested in trying it, but every few times I would log into my Hotmail account, I'd get a notice asking whether I'd like to try the new beta of Windows Live Mail. I finally decided that I might as well - not much could be worse than the existing Hotmail interface anyway.

The new layout is similar to that of Outlook and to the column view in the Mac OS Finder. On the farthest left column are your boxes - inbox, junk mail, trash. The next column consists of the messages in the box that you've selected, and the furthest right column consists of a "preview" of the message. Junk mail messages don't get an automatic preview; instead you have to authorize it.

Microsoft seems obsessed with the idea of a mail preview. Outlook, Outlook Express, and Entourage all come with that feature enabled, and I find it both annoying and potentially unsafe at the same time. While I think that a preview for webmail is less dangerous in terms of installing malicious software, it does bring up the idea of privacy. In case you're in a public environment, you may not want someone looking over your shoulder and seeing a personal email.

That said, by default when you sign in, no message is selected, but I could not find a way to just "go back to your inbox" when you're done reading a message.

It's still a beta, so it's buggy. Writing a new message didn't always work for me, and I got errors that said that my "request could not be processed" the first three times I tried to write a new email. Imagine that - an email application where I can't write a new message. I hope it gets fixed soon.

You can also change the color of the menus and accents on the page (which matters a great deal when reading email), and change the view from a column view to a vertically oriented one. There's also a "lite" version of the Live Mail page, which can be accessed if you feel that the pages are taking too long to load. Then again, if it's anything like Windows Vista, they should really have no less than five different versions....

Back to Gmail

I still prefer Gmail. I think it's a much more consumer-friendly application, and it's well written, lacking much of the awkwardness found in Hotmail.

For the record, though, I'm not totally bashing Microsoft. They've had their good products and services (Microsoft Word for Mac is excellent, the MSN Messenger service is generally good, and dare I say Windows 2000 Professional was actually a decent operating system. Too bad it went downhill with XP and continues to do so with Vista).

.mac Email

What if Apple were to make a version of its mac.com email available for users of any operating system for free? iTools, the predecessor to .mac, was a free service for Mac users where you had access to email and an "iDisk" as long as you had a Mac running Mac OS 9.

What if Apple were to allow the email portion to become free and give users a limited amount of storage? They could integrate it with iChat in a similar way that Microsoft has integrated Hotmail with Microsoft Messenger (where Messenger notifies you of new emails) so there's sort of a nice "plus" if you happen to be using the service as well as a Macintosh computer.

Nonpaying users could get say, 1 GB of storage and webmail access only, whereas paying users could get 3-4 GB of storage and the ability to integrate it with Apple's Mail software (or any other email client they choose).

Apple is in a better position in the market today than it was five years ago when mac.com was a free service. People know the Apple brand, know the image, and know what people are saying. They know iTunes, and they're starting to know the paranoia that Microsoft is creating by requiring its users to validate their software before installing any updates. They know the confusion of multiple versions of Windows and the user-interface disaster that is Hotmail.

If Apple were to provide free webmail, it would help to bring more people to the brand. They will soon understand that Apple isn't just a company that makes the Mac and the iPod, but also quality software and essentially all of the things necessary for the digital lifestyle. 

Recent Apple Archive articles

• iPods, notebooks, and other modern electronics more readily replaced than repaired, 12.07. Whether it's an intermittent failure or a broken display cable, more often than not it's cheaper to replace a broken electronics device than repair it.
• Options for replacing your older iPod, 11.19. Whether you've run out of space on your old iPod or want features it doesn't have, here are your options in new and used iPods.
• Could the $200 'green' PC with gOS Linux become a threat to Apple?, 11.14. The low cost, low power Everex desktop comes with a customized version of Ubuntu Linux, has a Mac-like Dock, and sells for $400 less than the Mac mini.
• Leopard different, a bit buggy, but worth the upgrade, 11.02. Leopard on a Power Mac G4 and a MacBook Pro: It runs well on both computers, but each has some odd bugs, and some of the changes are a step backwards.
• More in the Apple Archive index.

Links for the Day

• Mac of the Day: Power Mac 4400, Nov. 1996 - Apple does cheap to compete with clones - and nobody is impressed.
• List of the Day: Leopard List Low End Mac's email list covering Mac OS X 10.5.
  
• October 11 in LEM history: 99: Kihei revisited - 00: Bring back beige - AT&T proposes extortion - 01: Mimio for the Mac - 02: Of docks and roadblocks - Reasons not to switch - PowerBook G3 repair - 04: Virtual PC 7 puts Windows on your Mac - Modem Magic - 05: Why we oppose any iPod tax - Trash shortcuts - 06: 30 days of old school computing - Firefox and Safari chipping away at Microsoft

Recent Content on Low End Mac

• TruePower Battery Can Run WallStreet PowerBook Past the 5 Hour Mark, Tommy Thomas, Welcome to Macintosh, 10.10. If you have a rugged old PowerBook but its battery is losing capacity, TruePower can give you plenty of time in the field.
• nVidia Inside Next MacBook?, Time for a Mac Netbook, Asus Launched MacBook Air Killer, and More, The 'Book Review, 10.10. Also photo reveals more about MacBook Pro, comparing 16:9 and 16:10 displays, Apple settles suit over faulty iBook and PowerBook adapters, bargain 'Books from $150 to $2,699, and more.
• 30% of iPhone 3G Buyers Switched Carriers, EU Battery Rule May Force iPhone Redesign, and More, iNews Review, 10.10. Also iPhone 3G greatest consumer electronics device ever, track presidential polls on your iPhone, Talking English Dictionary, waterproof armbands, several new iPhone apps, and more.
• Economic Crunch May Slow Mac Sales, a Recycled Cube, ToCA Race Driver 3 for Mac, and More, Mac News Review, 10.10. Also don't buy RAM from Apple, customize your Mac's appearance, MacTribe expanding into print, My Apple Space social networking, and more.
• Best Mac Pro Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 10.10. Used 2.66 GHz 4-core, $1,799; new, $1,949 after rebate; 2.8 4-core, $2,099 shipped; 8-core, $2,599 shipped; 3.0 $3,399 shipped; 3.2, $4,099 shipped.
• Best PowerBook G3 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 10.10. Used 14" WallStreet G3/266 MHz, $90; Lombard G3/400 MHz, $150; Pismo G3/400 MHz, $300; 500 MHz, $350.
• Best Time Capsule and AirPort Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 10.10. Refurb 500 GB Time Capsule, $249; new, $294; refurb 1 TB, $419; new, $462; AirPort Extreme Card, $39; Base Station, $159; Express, $60.
• Modding Your Old Mac to Make It More Useful, Phil Herlihy, The Usefulness Equation, 10.09. If your old Mac is too slow, too noisy, too plain looking, or has too little room for expansion, you might want to mod it.
• What Would an $800 MacBook Mean for the Mac mini?, Dan Knight, Mac Musings, 10.09. If Apple does release an $800 entry-level MacBook next week, the $600 Mac mini is going to look very overpriced.
• Best iMac G4 Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 10.09. Used 15" 700 MHz CD-RW, $269; 800 Combo, $300; 1 GHz, $390; 17" 1.25 GHz SuperDrive, $400; 20", $529.
• Best 15" MacBook Pro Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 10.09. Used 1.83 GHz Core Duo, $995; 2.16, $1,125; new, 2.2, $1,400 after rebate; refurb 2.4, $1,699; 2.5, $1,999; 2.6, $2,299; rebates on new.
• Best Mac OS X 10.4 'Tiger' Deals, Low End Mac Deals, 10.09. DVD upgrade from 10.3, $75; upgrade bundle with 10.3, $118; full version, $129; family pack, $200; 10-user Server, $350; unlimited, $400.
• The Power of Older Macs, Why Vista Only Sees 3 GB of RAM, Wangwriter Supplies, and More, Charles W. Moore, Miscellaneous Ramblings, 10.08. Also the end of an era as MIT HyperArchive shuts down and another suggestion for profiling Windows computers.
• Migrating My Law Office from Windows to Macintosh, Andrew J Fishkin, Best Tools for the Job, 10.08. By switching to Leopard Server, everyone in the office will be able to move to a Mac - but which ones will best meet their needs?
• Low End Mac Needs Help Moving to Joomla, Dan Knight, Mac Musings, 10.08. We've settled on Joomla as the content management system that should work very well for Low End Mac, but we're running stuck with templates.
• Will Apple's iPhone/App Store Tornado Blow Away the Competition?, Tim Nash, Taking Back the Market, 10.08. The iPod, iTunes, and the iTunes Store paved the way for the success of the iPhone and the App Store - and nobody can match that.
• More links in our archive.

About LEM | Support | Usage | Privacy | Contacts

Apple Archive articles copyright ©2000-07 by Adam Robert Guha. Entire Low End Mac website copyright ©1997-2008 by Cobweb Publishing, Inc., unless otherwise noted. All rights reserved. Advice presented in good faith, but what works for one may not work for all. Please report errors to .
  LINKS: We allow and encourage links to any public page as long as the linked page does not appear within a frame that prevents bookmarking it.
  Access our RSS news feed at http://lowendmac.com/feed.xml.
  Email may be published at our discretion; email addresses will not be published without permission, and we will encrypt them in hopes of avoiding spammers. If you prefer your message not be published, mark it "not for publication." Letters may be edited for length, context, and to match house style.
  PRIVACY: We don't collect personal information unless you explicitly provide it. For more details, see our Terms of Use.
  Low End Mac is an independent publication and has not been authorized, sponsored, or otherwise approved by Apple Inc. Apple, the Apple logo, Macintosh, iBook, iMac, eMac, iPod, iPhone, PowerBook, MacBook, MagSafe, Mac Pro, Apple TV, and AirPort are registered trademarks of Apple Inc. Additional company and product names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are hereby acknowledged.